New Block Draft for the Anti-Math Crowd

What if I said you could draft a torso block without all those pesky maths and measurements?  Would you laugh? Cry?  Call me crazy?  Would you help me test it?  Would you give me some advice?  Here’s the sitch…

This paper mockup was made without measurements, math, or ease.
This paper mockup was made without measurements, math, or ease.

I’ve been wanting to put together something more advanced than the basic conic block for a while now – something that addresses the upper torso and can serve as a base for later periods.  I’d been working in my normal sort of uber-mathsy direction, but my students have politely informed me that they really don’t like math as much as I do.  Also, they kinda think that my love of fractions is abnormal.  There’s a definitely preference for “physically inherent geometry” (ahem – folding) in the world today.

So, ok, fine, I get it….  No math.  No reading of a measuring tape.  No eighths of inches.  No imperial/metric debate.  No built-in assumptions about what shape you should be.  No ease, because it’s just not helpful for historical work.  No problems.  I’m guessing there will be some takers.  ;)

I'm still fussing with the armscye - I know where I went wrong and how to make it right.
It’s not 100% finished yet. I’m still fussing with the armscye – I know where I went wrong.

Paper is one of the least forgiving materials to use for a mockup, so I feel like this went relatively well.  It’s at a point where it’s trivial to alter to get the right fit, but it’s also pretty trivial to fix the method.

The back technically went better than the front at the arm, but the front error pulls it off.
The back technically went better than the front at the arm, but the front error pulls it off.  Start to finish time for the first attempt was about 40 minutes, which seems long, but I was taking pictures as I went.

Here’s my question for you, denizens of the interwebs: Is this the kind of thing where I should make a FaceBook page/group or a Google circle thing so people can share their experiences/pictures?  I would like to get feedback from people using the method once I finalize it and get it posted, but I am, like, Little Miss Social Media Impaired over here. What’s the most convenient forum for you all?  Or am I just being silly-pants?  What do I want to do here?

19 Comments

  1. this little lurker votes against Facebook, because she doesn’t want to get on there. Otherwise… No useful ideas. Mainly commented to ask if your method will work with real life people-bodies? I’ve been thinking about “draping” a paper sloper on myself as an alternative to measuring and drafting. Because paper has none of that silly stretch most fabrics have.

    1. *laugh* Thanks for delurking and commenting, e_Rugby – FB and I aren’t really friends either, but I’m willing to put out differences behind me if it means getting feedback on this one. ;)
      I designed the method to work for real bodies. The pitfall of draping with paper is that it doesn’t really drape, precisely. It crumples, creases, and refuses to make curves well. Draping on a live human is dicey because most people aren’t good at “now hold still!” Draping on yourself… Well, you can’t hold still. So that’s no bueno, right there. (Not to say I haven’t tried it. I have. Funny how there’s no demo of that action.) The other thing with full on draping is that a lot of people have a trouble keeping darts balanced (ie, both sides the same length). This is absolutely what the fabric wants to do, but I’ve noticed a human tendency to try to outwit muslin.

  2. Wow, I love the idea! Not that I mind the math, but this sounds promisingly similar to your earlier articles on How Things Might’ve Been Done Back Then. :-)

    I don’t want to get on Facebook either… In case you’d like to do it all in blog posts, maybe you could post a part 1 that is enough to get people started, and then add a part 2 (and/or revise part 1) based on the feedback in the comments?

    1. Hi, Anna-Carin – Your guess is prolly pretty close to what I’ve been working with, although I am going to skip the traditional strip-of-paper-with-all-measurements business. ;) I’m down with a feedback post. Thanks for the suggestion!

    1. Hi, Jenn – I’m using my flat pattern class as my first round of test hansters. We’re starting tonight – yipes! But we should leave with skirt blocks to test, do bodices next tuesday, and combine to torso next thursday. :) I’m very excited, but also hoping this doesn’t fall flat on its face.

    1. Hi, LadyD – Yes, I can believe that! If it’s waxed baking paper instead of the parchment kind, it does have an advantage: you can iron pieces together so seams and darts stay closed to get an idea of fit.

  3. Lurker here too, I find for these sorts of detailed things, especially if pictures are involved that Facebook isn’t a great medium for that. You would have to create a document and upload that to a group folder for it to be logical and easy to follow. I personally do still prefer blogs…. I have been following yours for many years now. Use some of ideas even as well! :)

    1. Hi, Suzanne – Thanks for the feedback. I hadn’t even thought of how to get the pictures on to Facebook. Shows how much I know about all that! I feel slightly less guilty now. Thank you. :) Glad you’ve found things here helpful, and I hope that continues going forward!

  4. More so now than ever before I think, partially because I am patterning more for myself with normal everyday stuff and not just costumes anymore. Your tricks often make the difference! :)

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.